Delaware Corporate Law Update

Updates on Delaware Corporate Law by Evan O. Williford, Esq., Delaware Corporate Litigation Attorney.

What’s the Big Deal with Blockchain?

Over the past year or so there has been a good deal of discussion about using “blockchain” technology as a method to store corporate records, particularly about stockholders.  But what exactly is blockchain anyway, and is it coming soon to a Delaware corporation near you?

What is “blockchain”?  Blockchain technology was invented by the unidentified founder (alias “Satoshi Nakamoto”) of, and used in the establishment of, the currency “bitcoin”.  For those who have been living under a rock for the past ten years, bitcoin is a type of money that operates without a central authority and, as of January 11, 2018, had a market capitalization of approximately $240 billion.

Blockchain technology operates by replacing a single record-book with multiple identical record-books maintained by a network of participants.  For instance, with respect to bitcoin, it has enabled the creation of an entirely electronic currency (no actual coins or counterfeit-proof paper bills needed) without the necessity for a central authority to keep records of it (which central authority would need to be trusted and possibly paid by transaction fees).

There are several ways that technology has, both generally and with respect to bitcoin, to reduce the possibility of fraud.  For instance, it can apply decision rules to resolve disputes, such as when copies of the record-book disagree with others as to a transaction.

So what is the connection to Delaware corporate law?  One way in which blockchain technology shows promise is as a replacement for record-books of corporate stockholders.  As corporate lawyers know, but John Q. Stockholder might be surprised to learn, “stockholders” of large publicly held Delaware corporations frequently don’t hold their own shares.

Rather, they are what the law calls “beneficial owners”.  For historical reasons, the system that has evolved in the Unites States is that most such shares of stock are held by an organization called Depository Trust Company (“DTC”) and issued in the name of its nominee, Cede & Company (“Cede”).

So, if a “beneficial owner” wishes to vote their shares, they frequently must tell their broker to tell Cede to vote the way they want or use some other equivalent process.  This can give rise to costly unfair results.  For instance, in one phase of the Dell appraisal litigation, because the name of the stockholder of record changed, Delaware law requiring continuous ownership of shares was violated, resulting in a lost potential damages award.  In another, a mistaken instruction cost a stockholder a potential $200 million award.

One of the long-term promises of blockchain technology is to replace DTC, thereby reunifying beneficial and record ownership and hopefully eliminating some potentially unfair results under Delaware law.  A recently published article by Vice Chancellor J. Travis Laster and Skadden Arps lawyer Marcel Rosner, Distributed Stock Ledgers and Delaware Law, 73 Bus. Law. 319 (Spring 2018), goes into detail regarding blockchain technology and the promise it holds for various facets of Delaware law, and is recommended reading for those looking for a deeper understanding.

Is blockchain technology coming to a Delaware corporation near me?  The answer is maybe, but slowly.  The Delaware General Corporation Law was amended in 2017 to permit, theoretically and under certain conditions, keeping corporate records like stock ownership in blockchain format.  That being said, law and corporate America can be conservative.  The path is open for enterprising Delaware corporations to use and show the success of blockchain recordkeeping, and perhaps others will follow.

In the meantime, as Vice Chancellor Laster recommended in the first Dell decision discussed above, Delaware courts (or the Delaware legislature, for that matter), could consider changing Delaware law to ameliorate these argued unfair results.

Advertisements

Filed under: Appraisal, Court of Chancery

Pages

Disclaimer

Delaware Corporate Law Update solely reflect the views of Evan Williford of The Williford Firm, LLP. Its purpose is to provide general information concerning Delaware law; no representation is made about the accuracy of any information contained herein, and it may or may not be updated to reflect subsequent relevant events. This website is not intended to provide legal advice. It does not form any attorney-client relationship and it is not a substitute for one.